Classic Rockers Network

Classic Rock Fan Community: Led Zep, Rolling Stones, Beatles, Doors & More

My review of the review of Led Zeppelin I, from Rolling Stone, 1969

The popular formula in England in this, the aftermath era of such successful British bluesmen as Cream and John Mayall, seems to be: add, to an excellent guitarist who, since leaving the Yardbirds and/or Mayall, has become a minor musical deity, a competent rhythm section and pretty soul-belter who can do a good spade imitation. The latest of the British blues groups so conceived offers little that its twin, the Jeff Beck Group, didn't say as well or better three months ago, and the excesses of the Beck group's Truth album (most notably its self-indulgence and restrictedness), are fully in evidence on Led Zeppelin's debut album.

Jimmy Page, around whom the Zeppelin revolves, is, admittedly, an extraordinarily proficient blues guitarist and explorer of his instrument's electronic capabilities. Unfortunately, he is also a very limited producer and a writer of weak, unimaginative songs, and the Zeppelin album suffers from his having both produced it and written most of it (alone or in combination with his accomplices in the group).

The album opens with lots of guitarrhythm section exchanges (in the fashion of Beck's "Shapes of Things" on "Good Times Bad Times," which might have been ideal for a Yardbirds' B-side. Here, as almost everywhere else on the album, it is Page's guitar that provides most of the excitement. "Babe I'm Gonna Leave You" alternates between prissy Robert Plant's howled vocals fronting an acoustic guitar and driving choruses of the band running down a four-chord progression while John Bonham smashes his cymbals on every beat. The song is very dull in places (especially on the vocal passages), very redundant, and certainly not worth the six-and-a-half minutes the Zeppelin gives it.

Two much-overdone Willie Dixon blues standards fail to be revivified by being turned into showcases for Page and Plant. "You Shook Me" is the more interesting of the two — at the end of each line Plant's echo-chambered voice drops into a small explosion of fuzz-tone guitar, with which it matches shrieks at the end.

The album's most representative cut is "How Many More Times." Here a jazzy introduction gives way to a driving (albeit monotonous) guitar-dominated background for Plant's strained and unconvincing shouting (he may be as foppish as Rod Stewart, but he's nowhere near so exciting, especially in the higher registers). A fine Page solo then leads the band into what sounds like a backwards version of the Page-composed "Beck's Bolero," hence to a little snatch of Albert King's "The Hunter," and finally to an avalanche of drums and shouting.

In their willingness to waste their considerable talent on unworthy material the Zeppelin has produced an album which is sadly reminiscent of Truth. Like the Beck group they are also perfectly willing to make themselves a two- (or, more accurately, one-a-half) man show. It would seem that, if they're to help fill the void created by the demise of Cream, they will have to find a producer (and editor) and some material worthy of their collective attention.

Oh, where to begin. How about at the beginning??  This is a review of  a review of Led Zeppelin’s debut by John Mendelsohn of Rolling Stone Magazine from March, 1969. Mendelsohn makes numerous comparisons to Jeff Beck’s Truth  album, of course there are similarities, they were both in the Yardbirds, at one point, at the same time! In his comparisons of Plant and Stewart he says “…but he's (Plant) nowhere near so exciting, especially in the higher registers” with this I disagree, taking nothing away from Rod Stewart, who is certainly a pop/rock legend and icon, but he certainly doesn’t have the range or power of Robert Plant, in fact, I would say the opposite is true, it is Stewart who lacks the excitement of Plant. One of my favorite Plant vocals comes at the end of You Shook Me, where he carries that note on the word “all” with such amazing power, there’s no way Stewart could pull that off.  Plant is most certainly not “prissy”, and is very convincing!!

He does get one thing right when he says that Page is “an extraordinarily proficient blues guitarist and explorer of his instrument's electronic capabilities”. But he then goes on to call Page a limited producer and weak song writer, moreover, according to Mr. Mendelsohn, the songs are unimaginative, boring  and monotonous (in some places). Nothing could be further from the Truth, pun semi-intended. The songs are, in fact, full of excitement and brilliant musicianship, Mendelsohn comments “while John Bonham smashes his cymbals on every beat” in this context, he says this like it’s a bad thing.  Even on their debut album, I could see what a powerful and talented drummer John Bonham was. At the end of the review, he refers to ‘the Zeppelin’ as “a two- (or, more accurately, one-a-half) man show”, I assume he is referring to Page and Plant here, furthermore, he makes zero reference to John Paul Jones’ amazing keyboard and bass playing, which takes center stage on the keyboard intro of Your Time Is Gonna Come. I could go on forever, but I want this to be a review of the review and not an angry rant of a review, against my all time favorite band.

The last sentences of the review are the most absurd: “It would seem that, if they're to help fill the void created by the demise of Cream, they will have to find a producer (and editor) and some material worthy of their collective attention”.

Jimmy Page is a great producer, always has been, always will be. And while Cream was also a great band, with very talented musicians, they will never have the impact that Led Zeppelin has had on the music industry and its history. All I can say is that John Mendelsohn must be kicking himself and wondering to himself “What the hell was I thinking??”




Views: 158


You need to be a member of Classic Rockers Network to add comments!

Join Classic Rockers Network

network founder!
Comment by Rich Page on May 25, 2011 at 2:14pm
Great review - I was always a little miffed by the Rolling Stone poor review of their first album.

Most Popular Discussions 

Featured CRN Content!

The True Definition of Classic Rock!

Come debate the true definition of classic rock!

List of Great Classic Rock Cover Bands To See
Relive your classic rock favorite bands with these great cover bands.

© 2024   Created by Rich Page.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service

News: Check out our full concert videos Led Zep, The Who, Hendrix and more!